Roaming Coverage
The rationalizations against the wisdom at looking at the big picture when it comes to roaming coverage are truly amazing because they apply to so few subscribers. I.e. one Cingular aficionado wrote: "I have several colleagues who don't even take their phones with them when they leave their home area. They view the phone as an anchor." I certainly agree that if you never leave your home area and the lowest cost provider has good coverage, that indeed selecting that carrier makes sense. But most people do travel at least occasionally. Business people want good coverage in the cities they travel to, leisure travelers often go to (or through) rural areas where they very much want the reassurance of a working mobile phone. Some urban areas do not have any GSM coverage at all.
If you never leave your home area than you can skip this section. If you travel, for business or pleasure, and would like your phone to function in areas where wireless service is available, then pay close attention!
On-Network Roaming, Plans & Coverage |
|
Rank | Carrier |
1 | Verizon |
2 | Sprint |
3 | AT&T |
4 | Nextel |
5 | Cingular/T-Mobile |
Off-Network Roaming Plans & Coverage |
|
Rank | Carrier |
1,2 (tie) | AT&T (TMDA)/Verizon |
3 | Sprint |
4 | AT&T (GSM) |
5 | Cingular/T-Mobile |
7 | Nextel (no off-network roaming) |
Sprint now has a plan that lets you use up to 50% of your peak minutes to roam off-network. You have to sign up at a store or by phone, you can't do it on the web site for some reason. The plan with roaming is called the "PCS Free and Clear America" plan. Their "Free and Clear" plan is only for their own network, which is smaller than Verizon or AT&T's network. If you don't often travel outside of Sprint coverage then it's okay to just pay for the occasional roaming (especially if you're on a low-priced Sprint retention plan).
Verizon lets you roam onto some of Sprint and Alltel as part of America's Choice, and also has the "National Single Rate" plan that lets you roam completely off-network.
AT&T doesn't let you roam onto other carriers on their "AT&T Wireless National Network" plan. This can be a problem as there are many areas of the country where AT&T does not have service, including some medium sized cities. There is always the Digital One Rate plan for those customers that need to go off-network a lot, but it is much more expensive.
Off-Network roaming can cost the provider a lot of money. This is why they tend to discourage it by making the off-network roaming plans so expensive, and by not including loads of off-peak minutes. They also don't allow people that don't live in their local coverage area to sign up for service.
American
Roaming Network (ARN) |
The FCC mandates that wireless carriers provide roaming
services to all customers, even if the customer's carrier does not have a
roaming agreement with the carrier in the customer's physical location at
any given time. While this requirement does not extend to unregistered
handsets, if you have an unregistered AMPS capable phone you may be able to use
it on the American Roaming Network to make credit card and collect calls.
The charges are very
high, typically $2-3 per minute.
Not all carriers may be complying with the manual roaming requirement. A Usenet poster stated that Verizon does not complete credit card calls on AMPS. |
Cingular GAIT Handsets (Information on the Nokia 6340i and the Sony Ericsson T62u have been moved to a separate page)
Watch Your Roaming Indicator,
Verizon is Again Decreasing America's Choice Roaming Coverage
Verizon has removed quite a bit of included roaming from America's Choice,
turning it into extra cost roaming, Click
for Details.
Bottom Line on Roaming Coverage
AT&T and Verizon are the best
choices for nationwide roaming. Verizon has the edge with the on-network plan,
because America's Choice includes roaming onto other carriers in many areas
where Verizon has no coverage, while on AT&T you have to be on the more
expensive Digital One
Rate to get any off-network nationwide roaming.
|
Return to New York City Cellular Carrier Comparison Return to San Francisco Bay Area Cellular Carrier Comparison |
|